Unlocking the Power of Equity Compensation

Equity compensation serves as a strategic alternative to traditional salaries, offering employees a stake in the company's ownership instead of immediate cash rewards. While initially lacking immediate returns, it entices skilled professionals, especially in startups facing cash constraints.

By granting shares, startups can attract top talent without straining initial cash flow. For example, hiring a chief technology officer may mean paying less money but giving them a big ownership stake. This new structure is becoming popular in startup job contracts, connecting employee interests with the company's long-term success.

How is Equity Paid Out? 

Every company structures its equity payouts uniquely, primarily using vested equity and granted stock. Vested equity involves scheduled payments outlined in a contract, while granted stock is given at the contract's start.

While appealing, accepting equity instead of or alongside a salary involves risk. It's important to know the deal's structure and the type of equity being offered. Sometimes, what looks like equity is actually options to buy equity. Moreover, these options might differ from those held by founders, adding complexity. 

The rules can be strict. Employees are required to use options soon after they leave. They are also required to buy equity without knowing if the company will succeed. Additionally, they do not know if the equity will be valuable in the future.

Types of Equity Compensation

Equity compensation comes in different forms.

Stock Options

In many companies, employees have the opportunity to purchase company shares at a predetermined price. These programs motivate employees to care about the company's success and connect their financial goals to the company's performance.

Employee stock options often have a waiting period before employees can sell or transfer the shares. This waiting period is designed to encourage long-term commitment and discourage short-term speculation.

Employees are encouraged to hold onto their stock options. This allows them to benefit from any potential increase in the company's stock price. They should refrain from selling or transferring the shares immediately.

It's important to note that employee stock options often come with expiry dates. This means that employees are required to exercise their options and purchase company shares within a certain timeframe. If they fail to do so within the specified period, the options expire and become worthless.

Restricted Stock 

Restricted stock is a type of compensation often provided to executives and directors of a company. When individuals are granted restricted stock, they are not immediately granted full ownership rights over the shares. Instead, they must undergo a vesting period, during which they earn ownership rights over the stock.

The vesting period for restricted stock is typically determined by the company and can vary in duration. The vesting period usually lasts for many years. The person receiving the shares must stay employed by the company to keep earning ownership rights. Executives or directors who leave early may lose some or all their restricted stock.

Compared to stock options, which may also have vesting requirements, restricted stock grants ownership rights upfront, albeit with restrictions. Stock options give the recipient the right to purchase shares at a predetermined price. However, the recipient does not actually own the shares until they exercise the options. In contrast, restricted stock is actual ownership of the shares, albeit subject to certain restrictions during the vesting period.

It is worth noting that restricted stock is subject to certain tax implications. If the recipient fully owns the stock, they may have to pay taxes on its value. This applies whether they decide to sell it or not.

Restricted stock is taxed differently in each country. Therefore, it is crucial for recipients to consult with tax professionals. This will help them comprehend the specific effects of taxation.

Restricted stock is a common way to pay executives and directors. It gives them a share in the company's success and makes sure their goals match the shareholders'.

Employee Stock Purchase Plan

The ESPP is a program for employees to buy company shares at a lower price. One of the main advantages of participating in an ESPP is the tax benefits it offers to employees.

When workers join an ESPP, they can usually set aside some of their pay to the plan using payroll deductions. Contributions are made after taxes are taken out of the employee's income. This is different from other retirement plans like a 401(k) where contributions are typically made before taxes.

Employees' contributions are collected over a specific time, like six months or a year, called the offering period. At the end, the saved money is used to buy company shares for the employees. The price of shares is determined by the lower fair market value at the start or end of the offering period. A discount is applied to encourage employees to participate.

Once the shares are purchased, they are typically held in a brokerage account in the employee's name. These shares are not immediately owned by the employee, so they don't have full ownership rights over them. Instead, there is usually a vesting period, which can vary depending on the company's policies. 

Employees must meet certain requirements to fully own the shares they purchased. One of these requirements is staying with the company for a specific period of time.

One of the key advantages of an ESPP is the tax advantage it offers to employees. When the shares bought through the plan are sold later, any profits from the sale may be eligible for tax benefits.

In some cases, these profits may be eligible for lower tax rates known as long-term capital gains tax rates. These rates are typically lower than regular income tax rates. This could result in significant tax savings for employees compared to if they had purchased the shares on the open market. 

ESPPs are only for employees, not for contractors, consultants, or non-employed board members or shareholders. This rule makes sure that only employees who actively contribute to the company's success can receive the plan's benefits.

The Employee Stock Purchase Plan is a good benefit for employees to own shares in their company. It offers tax advantages and can be a powerful tool for building wealth over time.

Performance Shares

Performance shares are a form of payment for executives and directors. They are given based on their success in meeting company-set performance targets. Performance shares aim to align executives' and directors' interests with shareholders' interests.

Goals for earning performance shares are typically set beforehand. These goals are based on important measures of success that are relevant to the company's industry and goals.

Each organization has different goals. However, there are common metrics that are used to measure these goals. These metrics include financial targets such as revenue growth, earnings per share, return on investment, and market share.

Performance shares can be issued even if goals aren't fully met when exceptional performance occurs. Executives and directors are motivated to exceed their goals and achieve exceptional outcomes due to this added incentive. By rewarding exceptional performance, companies can encourage a culture of excellence and high achievement among their top leadership. 

The allocation of performance shares is typically subject to specific vesting schedules and conditions. Executives and directors will receive the benefits of these shares under two conditions. The first condition is that they must remain with the company for a predetermined period of time. The second condition is that they must achieve specific performance goals within a specified timeframe.

This ensures that individuals receiving performance shares are dedicated to the success of the organization. Their rewards are based on their performance over time.

Bottom Line

In navigating the complexities of equity compensation, understanding its diverse forms becomes paramount. There are different types of stock options that offer various benefits and factors to consider. These include long-term commitment, ownership rights, tax advantages, and employee stock purchase plans. Performance shares, tied to achieving goals, incentivize leaders to steer towards shareholder value. 

As this landscape evolves, the importance of fair, transparent employment agreements and equitable treatment of employees remains pivotal. Making informed decisions and seeking professional guidance can lead to a clearer path for benefiting from equity compensation. This can also promote mutual growth and success between employees and their companies.

Sources:

https://www.business.com/articles/equity-as-compensation/

Disclosures:

This information is an overview and should not be considered as specific guidance or recommendations for any individual or business.

This site may contain links to articles or other information that may be on a third-party website. Advisory Services Network, LLC is not responsible for and does not control, adopt, or endorse any content contained on any third-party website.

This material is provided as a courtesy and for educational purposes only.  Please consult your investment professional, legal or tax advisor for specific information pertaining to your situation.

These are the views of the author, not the named Representative or Advisory Services Network, LLC, and should not be construed as investment advice. Neither the named Representative nor Advisory Services Network, LLC gives tax or legal advice. All information is believed to be from reliable sources; however, we make no representation as to its completeness or accuracy. Please consult your Financial Advisor for further information.